Surgery for back pain.
When yes, when no.
Last updated Sources checked
How this page was writtenInjections & surgery
NICE NG59 · Dutch LRS guideline
How do we rate this?
We look at whether the pain decreases and whether people can move and function better again, not at how satisfied patients were with the treatment, because that says little about whether it really works. Independent reviews and bodies such as Cochrane, the WHO, NICE and the Zorginstituut weigh most. When a profession recommends its own treatment, that alone does not earn a high score. Strong comparative research is scarce for back pain, so some ratings are based on limited evidence.
Score per procedure
Emergency surgery for cauda equina syndrome
Necessary and urgent. Operating cannot be tested against not operating, so the evidence is observational.
No score: there is no alternativeHerniated disc surgery after 10 to 12 weeks of persistent radiating pain
Relieves faster; after one to two years the result is comparable.
Decompression for spinal canal stenosis
Reasonable option after failed conservative care, but the evidence is mixed.
Spinal fusion for non-specific back pain
Not better than intensive rehabilitation. NICE advises against it.
Whether an operation helps depends entirely on what is actually wrong. For a rare emergency it is necessary and urgent. For ordinary back pain without a clear cause there is no good evidence that it helps. Those two extremes sit under the same word, which is why this page splits them out.
When surgery IS needed
No score: there is no alternativeHow do we rate this?
We look at whether the pain decreases and whether people can move and function better again, not at how satisfied patients were with the treatment, because that says little about whether it really works. Independent reviews and bodies such as Cochrane, the WHO, NICE and the Zorginstituut weigh most. When a profession recommends its own treatment, that alone does not earn a high score. Strong comparative research is scarce for back pain, so some ratings are based on limited evidence.
Cauda equina syndrome Emergency surgery
Loss of bladder or bowel control, saddle-shaped numbness, increasing weakness in both legs. Surgery should happen as soon as possible, ideally within 48 hours. Decompression within about 48 hours gives a better chance of recovering bladder function and muscle strength than later surgery (Ahn et al., 2000). That evidence comes from observational studies, because operating cannot be tested against not operating; that is why there is no score here, not because there is doubt. This is a rare but serious emergency.
Progressive severe neurological deficit
Increasing muscle weakness from a herniated disc, for example a foot you can lift less and less. Do not wait: call your GP straight away (NHG). Sometimes a quick operation is needed (Dutch Association of Neurosurgeons).
Discectomy (herniated disc surgery)
How do we rate this?
We look at whether the pain decreases and whether people can move and function better again, not at how satisfied patients were with the treatment, because that says little about whether it really works. Independent reviews and bodies such as Cochrane, the WHO, NICE and the Zorginstituut weigh most. When a profession recommends its own treatment, that alone does not earn a high score. Strong comparative research is scarce for back pain, so some ratings are based on limited evidence.
In a discectomy the protruding part of a disc that presses on a nerve is removed. Start with the natural course: the Dutch guideline for lumbosacral radicular syndrome (2020) reports a median symptom duration of 16 days, and about 75% of people have substantially recovered after three months without any surgery.
The Sciatica Trial (Peul et al., NEJM 2007) showed that surgery provides faster pain relief, but that after one to two years the results are equal to conservative treatment (Peul et al., BMJ 2008). The Dutch guideline therefore advises discussing surgery after 10 to 12 weeks of insufficient improvement, as a shared decision. Around 40% of the people who first choose to wait are eventually operated on anyway.
There is an important nuance to “it evens out anyway”. Bailey et al. (NEJM 2020) studied people whose sciatica had already lasted 4 to 12 months. In that group microdiscectomy was clearly better than standardised non-operative care at 6 and 12 months. So waiting is sensible early on, but endlessly postponing is not automatically the better choice.
About the technique: the Dutch PTED trial (Gadjradj et al., BMJ 2022) randomised 613 patients across four hospitals and found that keyhole surgery through the side (PTED) is not inferior to conventional open microdiscectomy. Both are defensible; the choice mostly depends on what your hospital is experienced in.
Decompression for spinal canal stenosis
How do we rate this?
We look at whether the pain decreases and whether people can move and function better again, not at how satisfied patients were with the treatment, because that says little about whether it really works. Independent reviews and bodies such as Cochrane, the WHO, NICE and the Zorginstituut weigh most. When a profession recommends its own treatment, that alone does not earn a high score. Strong comparative research is scarce for back pain, so some ratings are based on limited evidence.
With a narrowed spinal canal the nerves get too little room, typically causing pain and heaviness in the legs when walking that eases when you sit or bend forward. In a decompression the surgeon removes bone and thickened ligament to create space.
NICE (recommendation 1.3.8) says to consider spinal decompression for sciatica when non-surgical treatment has not improved pain or function and the imaging matches the symptoms. The evidence is genuinely mixed: a Cochrane review (2016) found no clear benefit of surgery over non-surgical treatment, while reporting complications in 10 to 24% of participants in the surgical groups of the studies that recorded them.
One thing is clear: do not let a fusion be added without a good reason. Försth et al. (NEJM 2016) randomised 247 patients and found that adding fusion to decompression gave no better outcome at 2 and 5 years, while it did mean a longer operation, a longer hospital stay and higher costs.
Spinal fusion (spondylodesis)
Not recommended for non-specificHow do we rate this?
We look at whether the pain decreases and whether people can move and function better again, not at how satisfied patients were with the treatment, because that says little about whether it really works. Independent reviews and bodies such as Cochrane, the WHO, NICE and the Zorginstituut weigh most. When a profession recommends its own treatment, that alone does not earn a high score. Strong comparative research is scarce for back pain, so some ratings are based on limited evidence.
Fusing vertebrae for non-specific back pain is not more effective than intensive rehabilitation. Two trials compared the two and found no clear benefit of fusion: Brox et al. (Spine 2003) and the British MRC Spine Stabilisation Trial (Fairbank et al., BMJ 2005). A Swedish trial that compared fusion with ordinary non-surgical care did find a modest benefit, at the cost of more complications (Fritzell et al., Spine 2001); the comparison group there did not get intensive rehabilitation. NICE is blunt about it: do not offer spinal fusion for low back pain unless as part of a randomised controlled trial.
May be considered for: unstable vertebral fractures, spondylolisthesis with neurological deficit, a tumour or infection, or severe instability not responding to other treatments. Those are specific diagnoses, not a description of ordinary back pain.
The same applies to an artificial disc. NICE (recommendation 1.3.10) states plainly: do not offer disc replacement in people with low back pain.
Figures from the Netherlands
About 11,000 herniated disc operations are performed in the Netherlands every year, more than 9,000 of them by neurosurgeons. Roughly 1 in 7 people with a symptomatic herniation is operated on; the rest recover without surgery. In 5 to 10% of cases a herniation comes back (Dutch Association of Neurosurgeons).
That same leaflet also says 80 to 90% of people operated on are satisfied with the result. We have deliberately left that number out. Being satisfied is not the same as your pain and your limitations actually having gone down, and it is the second thing we look at on this site. It also comes from the leaflet of the profession that performs the operation.
An operation is not a guarantee. Of nearly 7,000 Dutch patients operated on between July 2015 and June 2016, 23% needed treatment againafterwards: another operation, a nerve root block, or strong painkillers. The painkillers were the largest group, a good 1 in 7 (Schepens et al., Global Spine Journal 2023).
And where you live matters, though less than is often claimed. A study covering every Dutch adult between 2016 and 2019 looked at 119,000 people with these complaints, of whom nearly 15,000 had surgery. For the hernia operation itself, the chance differed by less than a factor of two between postcode areas. Where it does run far apart is fusion surgery: there the chance was up to five times higher in one postcode area than in another (van Munster et al., 2024). Good reason to ask which operation is being proposed, and why that one.
Questions to ask before you agree
- What exactly is the diagnosis, and does the scan match my symptoms?
- What happens if I wait another six weeks? What would change?
- Which part of my symptoms do you expect the operation to solve: the leg pain, the back pain, or both?
- What is the chance I will still have pain afterwards?
- How many of these procedures do you perform each year?
- Which non-surgical options have not been tried yet?
And remember: you are entitled to a second opinion. If you ask for a referral, your doctor has to cooperate unless there are compelling reasons not to (KNMG). For an irreversible procedure on your spine, that is a reasonable thing to use.
Herniated disc with sciatica: the usual path
Week 0–6
Conservative first
Keep moving, physiotherapy if needed. About 75% recovers within three months.
Week 6–12
Evaluation
Still in a lot of pain? Then your GP will usually refer you to a neurologist, sooner if you have weakness.
After that
Deciding together
Surgery relieves faster; after one to two years the result is comparable.
Emergency
Act straight away
Cauda equina or increasing weakness: call your GP straight away, or the out-of-hours GP service outside office hours.
Key message
There is no single answer to “does back surgery work”. For cauda equina syndrome it is urgent and necessary. For a herniated disc with persistent radiating pain it is a reasonable choice after 10 to 12 weeks, mainly because it relieves faster. For back pain without a clear cause, fusion and disc replacement are not recommended. Ask which of these situations applies to you, and ask for a second opinion if the answer stays vague.
Sources
- Ahn UM, et al. Cauda equina syndrome secondary to lumbar disc herniation: a meta-analysis of surgical outcomes. Spine (2000)
- Peul WC, et al. Surgery versus prolonged conservative treatment for sciatica. NEJM (2007)
- Peul WC, et al. Prolonged conservative care versus early surgery in patients with sciatica caused by lumbar disc herniation: two year results of a randomised controlled trial. BMJ (2008)
- Bailey CS, et al. Surgery versus conservative care for persistent sciatica lasting 4 to 12 months. NEJM (2020)
- Gadjradj PS, et al. Full endoscopic versus open discectomy for sciatica. BMJ (2022)
- Försth P, et al. A randomized, controlled trial of fusion surgery for lumbar spinal stenosis. NEJM (2016)
- Zaina F, et al. Surgical versus non-surgical treatment for lumbar spinal stenosis. Cochrane Database Syst Rev (2016)
- Brox JI, et al. Randomized clinical trial of lumbar instrumented fusion and cognitive intervention and exercises. Spine (2003)
- Fritzell P, et al. Lumbar fusion versus nonsurgical treatment for chronic low back pain. Spine (2001)
- Fairbank J, et al. MRC Spine Stabilisation Trial. BMJ (2005)
- Richtlijn Lumbosacraal Radiculair Syndroom (2020)
- NICE Guideline NG59 (2016)
- NHG-Standaard Aspecifieke lagerugpijn (2017, laatst gewijzigd 2024)
- Nederlandse Vereniging voor Neurochirurgie. Patiënteninformatie rughernia
- Schepens MHJ, et al. Outcomes After Lumbar Disk Herniation Surgery in the Dutch Population. Global Spine Journal (2023)
- van Munster JJCM, et al. Practice variation in surgical treatment for lumbar degenerative disc disease. Scientific Reports (2024)
Next step